KAGAN PELOPONNESIAN WAR PDF
Donald Kagan, The Peloponnesian War (New York: Viking, ), pp. It was Alfred North Whitehead who said that all Western philosophy is but a footnote. Donald Kagan. The Peloponnesian War. New York: Penguin Books, xxvii + pp. $ (paper), ISBN Reviewed by Janice J. The first volume of Donald Kagan’s acclaimed four-volume historyof the Peloponnesian War offers a new evaluation of the origins andcauses of the conflict, b.
|Published (Last):||12 May 2014|
|PDF File Size:||9.22 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||18.83 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
There are 29 excellent maps, spaced appropriately throughout the book, that provide the visual basis for understanding the narrative of the battles, and geopolitical landscape.
That said, I have a lot of respect for the author peloponneslan as his scholarship is concerned. There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Follow the Author
But in a way, these human foibles and failings make much of the story of the great war; and great it was, drawing in city-states far and wide, with a cast of characters that gives George RR Martin a run for his money meaning the literary Martin, not the televised. Share your thoughts with other customers.
Due to the original detail this account is also very detailed — often describing what were no more than minor skirmishes with a handful of dead on each side Condensed version of a multi-volume academic study into the war between Sparta and Athens in the 5th century BC, the book is mainly based around a famous historic account of the war by a contemporary of the events often regarded as the first real history book but at many times uses other sources to challenge the biases in that account.
You will need to turn to the tetralogy for those “scholarly” features. After Pericles death, the Athenians begin having some success on offense and adopt a more aggressive strategy. I read lots of programming books so i have – believe it or not, follow me here low tolerance for boredom.
The Peloponnesian War, however, inaugurated a period of brutality and destruction unprecedented in the Greek world. Beginning inKagan’s publication of the four-volume History of the Peloponnesian War established him as the leading authority on that seminal period in Greek history. I appreciated the explanations of Greek culture and political systems and could have done with a bit more of that.
In truth, I’m not sur This door-stopping tome is billed as “a readable narrative in a single volume to be read by the general reader for pleasure,” and that description makes me wonder what his four-volume complete history must have read like. Condensed version of a multi-volume academic study into the war between Sparta and Athens in the 5th century BC, the book is mainly based around a famous historic account of the war by a contemporary of the events often regarded as the first real history book but at many times uses other sources to challenge the biases in that account.
In the introduction, Kagan asserts that he wants to avoid the trap of describing the Peloponnesian War as a metaphor or parable for modern wars or the Cold War. The last chapters of the book are anti-climactic in my opinion. As a writer, Kagan seems to set his sights on clarity over any artistic effect, and we can say with confidence that he achieves his aims. Greece early on was moving from a true democracy to a “republic of the first citizen,” where a general or other man of consequence had actual power and sway beyond statutes.
Like any scholar worth his salt, Kagan is This book is wonderful because it takes Thucydides classic text–itself a wonder–and fills in the gaps, or corrects the ancient text where necessary. Their leaders are faulted for being overwhelmingly conservative and not taking advantage of moments of Athenian weakness, yet, when a dynamic Spartan leader emerges-like Brasidas or Lysander- he is faulted as being a sinister imperialist.
The Peloponnesian War
Without the gift of Thucydides’ own monumental narrative of the first 20 years of the war it is pretty clear that our knowledge and understanding of both the lessons and facts of that cataclysmic war would be fundamentally different and significant less. Although Kzgan am sure that Mr.
Donald Kagan is apparently the world’s foremost expert on this event, and his works peloponnesain it seem unassailable. For this purpose, the book is well suited since it both sums up some of the period covered by Thucydides and includes events that occurred after his death kqgan the end of the aar.
I especially like his analysis of the political structure and sentiments of the citizens of Athens, especially t A lot could be learned from this book, among them a full picture of the 5th century political and military struggles among the ancient Greeks, which is highly valuable because there is so few accounts left or ever existed for other ancient civilizations, and this author weren’t shy from giving speculations and interpretations, made the book highly readable, informative and insightful.
How would it work? If you’re not sure which book to read in order to learn about the Peloponnesian War, I would definitely read Kagan’s one book. I don’t really know why I read it. I had skimmed reviews and seen the general approval of the book when it came out so i gave it a chance. War Aims ;eloponnesian Resources His late wife of sixty-two years, Myrna Kaganwas a kgan and historian in her own right, and the author of Vision in the Sky: Perhaps, most importantly, this is an American book.
The Best Books of Explore the Home Gift Guide. Alexa Actionable Analytics for the Web. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Alas, I felt it a little overboard and in the end felt perversely glad that Athens fell. The rub, for me, came in deciding whether or not to read the 4 separate books that delve deeper or just satisfy myself with pages on the topic and move on. The story underlying it is amazing, and the writing is superb – clear, flowing, and with appropriate detail and connections drawn. Athens and their allies experience major defeats, which is foreboding for the next chapter of the conflict.
A minor quibble is that the conclusion is only 5 pages long and seems really inadequate compared to the proceeding pages.
Kagan’s The Peloponnesian War – AshbrookAshbrook
The Peloponnesiqn tradition has never been more accessible to Americans and English readers around the world. For three decades in the fifth century b. One person found this helpful.